How to Remove a Business Partner: Addressing Disputes Between Members of LLCs

In business, choosing the right partners is crucial because you will spend a lot of time working with them. However, disputes among members of a Limited Liability Company (LLC) in Ohio are not uncommon. These disagreements can range from financial issues to differences in business direction. Addressing these disputes effectively is crucial to maintaining the health and longevity of the company. This article explores the mechanisms for resolving disputes as outlined by Ohio statutes and the company's operating agreement and discusses the process for removing a member if disputes cannot be resolved amicably.

Resolving Member Disputes in an LLC (Ohio)

The Role of the Operating Agreement

The Ohio Revised Code (ORC) Chapter 1705 provides a legal framework for the operation of LLCs, including the resolution of member disputes. One primary method for dispute resolution is through the provisions of the LLC's operating agreement. This document, crafted by the members at the inception of the LLC, often contains specific procedures for handling disputes. It may include mediation or arbitration clauses that require disputes to be resolved through these less adversarial processes before any litigation can be pursued.

Mediation and Arbitration

Mediation involves a neutral third party who facilitates a resolution between the disputing members, while arbitration involves a neutral third party making a decision on the dispute after hearing arguments from both sides. ORC 1705.18 supports these methods by allowing members to include such provisions in their operating agreements. The benefits of mediation and arbitration include cost-effectiveness, time efficiency, and the preservation of business relationships among members. To take advantage of these options, the members must have them in their operating agreement or mutually agree upon them once a dispute arises. It is always better to plan ahead in the operating agreement than to wait for a dispute to surface.

Judicial Intervention

If mediation or arbitration is unsuccessful or not stipulated in the operating agreement, members may seek judicial intervention. The court can provide remedies such as injunctions, specific performance, or other relief deemed appropriate under the circumstances. However, litigation should be considered a last resort due to its public nature, expense, and potential to cause long-term damage to relationships and the LLC's operations.

Removing a Member from an LLC

In situations where a dispute cannot be resolved and the continued membership of a party is untenable, the ORC and the operating agreement may provide mechanisms for removing a member. ORC 1705.16 outlines the process for expulsion, which can be initiated by a vote of the other members or by court order in certain circumstances.

Grounds for Expulsion

However, not all disagreements are grounds for expulsion. The expulsion of a member can be based on certain conditions specified in the LLC's operating agreement, such as actions detrimental to the interests of the company, failure to meet capital contributions, or breach of the operating agreement.

Voting Procedures for Member Removal

The operating agreement may specify the percentage of votes required to remove a member. This democratic process allows members to make collective decisions about the composition of the LLC. The requirement could range from a simple majority to a unanimous decision, depending on what the operating agreement stipulates. It's important for the operating agreement to clearly define the grounds for removal and the voting process to prevent ambiguity and further disputes.

Court-Ordered Removal

In the absence of a clear provision in the operating agreement or if the members are unable to reach a decision, seeking a court order for removal may be necessary. The court will consider factors such as the nature of the dispute, the member's conduct, and the impact on the LLC's operations. This route can be complex and requires a compelling argument to justify the removal of a member against their will.

Conclusion

Disputes between members in an LLC can pose significant challenges to the operation and success of the business. Ohio law and the LLC's operating agreement provide various mechanisms for resolving disputes, from mediation and arbitration to judicial intervention. In cases where disputes cannot be resolved amicably, the law and the operating agreement may also provide for the removal of a member. It is essential for LLC members to proactively plan and include comprehensive dispute resolution and removal procedures in their operating agreements to minimize the risk of costly and disruptive conflicts.

‍